LinuxÄÚºËTCPºÍ̸¶à¸öSACKÖ°Äܻؾø·þÎñ·ì϶·ÖÎö

°ä²¼¹¦·ò 2019-06-21
·ì϶²¼¾°


2019Äê6ÔÂ18ÈÕ £¬Redhat°ä²¼°²È«²¼¸æ £¬LinuxÄÚºËTCP/IPºÍ̸ջ´æÔÚ3¸ö°²È«·ì϶£¨CVE-2019-11477/CVE-2019-11478/CVE-2019-11479£© £¬ÕâЩ·ì϶Óë×î´ó·Ö¶Î´óС£¨MSS£©ºÍTCPÑ¡ÔñÐÔÈ·ÈÏ£¨SACK£©Ö°ÄÜÓйØ £¬ÔÊÐíÔ¶³Ì¹¥»÷Õß½øÐлؾø·þÎñ¹¥»÷¡£


¹Ø¼ü¸ÅÏë



Êý¾Ý°ü³Á´«È·ÈÏ»úÔì


TCPÊý¾Ý°ü´«Êä¹ý³ÌÖÐ £¬À´×Ô»¬¶¯´°¿ÚµÄÊý¾Ý°üÃÔʧ¿ÉÄܶÔTCPÍÌÍÂÁ¿²úÉúÓ°Ïì¡£TCPʹÓÃÀÛ»ýÈ·ÈÏ£¨ACK£©¹æ»®½â¾ö¸ÃÎÊÌâ £¬ÆäÖв»½Ó¹Ü²»ÔÚ»¬¶¯´°¿Ú×ó±ßÔµµÄ½Ó¹Ü¶Î £¬Õâ»áÇ¿Ôì·¢ËÍ·½ÆÚ´ýÍù·µ¹¦·òÒÔÕÒ³öÿ¸öÃÔʧµÄÊý¾Ý°ü £¬»òÕß²»Óø¹µØ³Áд«ÊäÒÑÕýÈ·½Ó¹ÜµÄ¶Î £¬´Ó¶ø½µµÍÕûÌåÍÌÍÂÁ¿¡£


Ñ¡ÔñÐÔÈ·ÈÏ£¨SACK£©ÊÇÒ»ÖÖÔÚ¶à¸öÅׯúµÄ¶ÎµÄÇé¿öϽâ¾ö´ËÐÐΪµÄÕ½Êõ¡£Í¨¹ýÑ¡ÔñÐÔÈ·ÈÏ £¬Êý¾Ý½Ó¹Ü·½Äܹ»Ïò·¢ËÍ·½Í¨ÖªÒѳɹ¦´ïµ½µÄËùÓжÎ £¬Òò¶ø·¢ËÍ·½Ö»Ðè³Áд«ÊäÏÖʵÃÔʧµÄ¶Î¡£¾ßÌåÑ¡ÔñÐÔÈ·ÈϹý³Ì £¬ÈçÏÂͼËùʾ¡£


±¦ÔËÀ³¡¤(ÖйúÇø)×îйٷ½ÍøÕ¾


×î´ó·Ö¶Î´óС£¨Maximum Segment Size£©


MSS£¨Maximum Segment Size £¬×î´ó±¨ÎĶδóС£©µÄ¸ÅÏëÊÇÖ¸TCP²ãËù¿ÉÄܽӹܵÄ×î´ó·Ö¶Î´óÓ× £¬¸ÃÖµÖ»Ô̺¬TCP¶ÎµÄÊý¾Ý²¿ÃÅ £¬²»Ô̺¬Option²¿ÃÅ¡£Áí±í £¬ÔÚTCPÊײ¿ÓÐÒ»¸öMSSÑ¡Ïî £¬ÔÚÈý´ÎÎÕÊÖ¹ý³ÌÖÐ £¬TCP·¢ËͶËʹÓøÃÑ¡Ïî֪ͨ¶Ô·½×Ô¼ºËùÄܽÓÊܵÄ×î´ó·Ö¶Î´óÓס£


TSO£¨TCP Segmentation Offload£©


TSOÊÇÒ»ÖÖÀûÓÃÍø¿¨À´¶Ô´óÊý¾Ý°ü½øÐÐ×Ô¶¯·Ö¶Î £¬½µµÍCPU¸ºÔصļ¼Êõ¡£ÆäÖØÒªÊÇÑÓ³¤·Ö¶Î¡£


GSO(Generic Segmentation Offload)


GSOÊǺÍ̸ջÊÇ·ñÍÆ³Ù·Ö¶Î £¬ÔÚ·¢Ë͵½Íø¿¨Ö®Ç°ÅжÏÍø¿¨ÊÇ·ñÖ§³ÖTSO £¬ÈôÊÇÍø¿¨Ö§³ÖTSOÔòÈÃÍø¿¨·Ö¶Î £¬²»È»ºÍ̸ջ·ÖÍê¶ÎÔÙ½»¸øÇý¶¯¡£ÈôÊÇTSO¿ªÆô £¬GSO»á×Ô¶¯¿ªÆô¡£


·ì϶µÀÀí


CVE-2019-11477


ƾ¾Ý²¹¶¡¿ÉÖª £¬¸Ã·ì϶ÊÇÓÉÒ»¸ö16bitÎÞ·ûºÅÊýÒç³öµ¼ÖµÄ £¬¸ÃÎÞ·ûºÅÊý´æÔÚÈçϽṹÌåÖС£


±¦ÔËÀ³¡¤(ÖйúÇø)×îйٷ½ÍøÕ¾


¸Ãtcp_skb_cb½á¹¹Ìå´æ·Å×ÅTCPÿ¸öÊý¾Ý°üµÄ½ÚÔìÐÅÏ¢ £¬Æ¾¾Ý×¢½â¿ÉÖª £¬tcp_gso_segs/sizeÖ»ÓÃÓÚд¶ÓÁйý³ÌÖС£


LinuxÄÚºËTCP/IPºÍ̸ջʵÏÖÖÐ £¬Ã¿¸öÊý¾Ý»º³åÇøÊÇÓÉÒ»¸ösk_buff½á¹¹ÌåͳһÖÎÀíµÄ¡£ÔÚÒ»¸öÆëÈ«µÄÊý¾Ý»º³åÇøÖÐskb_endºóÃæ½ôËæ×ÅÒ»¸öskb_shared_info½á¹¹ÌåÊý¾Ý £¬skb_shared_info½á¹¹ÌåÈçÏÂËùʾ£º


±¦ÔËÀ³¡¤(ÖйúÇø)×îйٷ½ÍøÕ¾


½á¹¹Ìå×îºóÒ»¸ö³ÉÔ±ÊÇfrags[MAX_SKB_FRAGS]Êý¾Ý¡£MAX_SKB_FRAGSÉêÃ÷ÈçÏÂËùʾ£º

±¦ÔËÀ³¡¤(ÖйúÇø)×îйٷ½ÍøÕ¾


PAGE_SIZEΪ4KBÇé¿öÏ£¨¼´Ò»¸öÄÚ´æÒ³ÃæÎª4KB´óС£© £¬MAX_SKB_FRAGSȡֵΪ65536/4096 + 1¼´17 £¬Òò¶øÒ»¸öskbÖÐ×î¶à°üÈÝ17¸öÊý¾Ý·Ô쬡£¶ÔÓÚx86ϵͳ £¬Ã¿¸öÊý¾Ý·Ôì¬×î¶àÄܹ»¼Í¼32KBÊý¾ÝµÄ´óÓס£
Êý¾Ý·Ôì¬skb_frag_struct½á¹¹ÌåÈçÏÂËùʾ£º


±¦ÔËÀ³¡¤(ÖйúÇø)×îйٷ½ÍøÕ¾


ÔÚÕû¸öºÍ̸ջ²Ù×÷¹ý³ÌÖÐ £¬Êý¾Ý°ü¼ÈÒª½øÐÐIP±»·Ô쬵Ä £¬ÓÖÒª½øÐÐTCP·Ö¶Î¡£´«ÊäÊý¾Ýʱ £¬ºÍ̸ջ»áƾ¾ÝGSOÖµ £¬MSSÖµÒÔ¼°»¬¶¯´°¿ÚÈýÕßÖ®¼äµÄ´óÓ×¹ØÏµÅжÏÊÇ·ñ½øÐзÔ쬡£²¢Í¨¹ýtcp_set_skb_tso_segs()º¯ÊýÉèÖÃGSO £¬¾ßÌåʵÏÖÈçÏÂͼËùʾ£º


±¦ÔËÀ³¡¤(ÖйúÇø)×îйٷ½ÍøÕ¾


ÈôÊÇskb->len´óÓÚmss_now £¬ÐÐ1207 £¬½«tcp_gso_segsÉèÖÃΪskb->len/mss_now¡£ÐÐ1208 £¬½«tcp_gso_sizeÉèÖÃΪmss_now¡£


ÈôÊÇÆôÓÃÁËSACK £¬ÔÚ²úÉú¶ª°üºó £¬½Ó¹Ü¶Ë»á·µ»ØSACK¿é £¬SACK¿éÖмͼ³ÁÃÔʧ°üµÄÐòÁбàºÅ¡£·¢ËͶ˻á½âÎöSACK¿éÖмͼµÄÃÔʧ°üÐòÁбàºÅ £¬²¢³Áд«Êä £¬²¢ÇÒÔÚÒ»¸ö»¬¶¯´°¿ÚÖпÉÄÜÔ̺¬¶à¸öSACK¿é £¬SACK¿éÖÐÒ²¿ÉÄÜÔ̺¬¶à¸öskb¶ÓÁС£ÔÚTCP³Á´«Êý¾Ý°ü¹ý³ÌÖÐ £¬Äܹ»½«¶à¸öskb¶ÓÁй鲢µ½Ò»¸öskb¶ÓÁÐÖнøÐгÁ´«¡£


tcp_shift_skb_data()º¯ÊýʵÏÖÕâ¸öÖ°ÄÜ¡£³¢ÊÔ½«ÓâÔ½¶à¸öskbµÄSACK¿éÕÛµþΪһ¸öskb¡£¹Ø¼ü´úÂëÈçÏ£º


±¦ÔËÀ³¡¤(ÖйúÇø)×îйٷ½ÍøÕ¾


skb_shift()ºÍtcp_shifted_skb()Á½¸öº¯ÊýÖØÒªÊµÏÖ¸ÃÖ°ÄÜ¡£³Á´«¹ý³ÌÖжà¸öskb¶ÓÁй鲢µ½Ò»¸öskb¶ÓÁÐÖÐ £¬ÈôÊÇÌî³ä17¸ö·Ô쬵½×î´óÈÝÁ¿ £¬ 17*32*1024/8=69632 £¬ÒѾ­´óÓÚ65535 £¬µ¼ÖÂÎÞ·ûºÅÕûÊýÒç³ö¡£


ÔÚskb_shift ()º¯ÊýÖÐ £¬tcp_gso_segsÒç³öºó £¬½øÈëtcp_shifted_skb()º¯Êýºó £¬ÈçÏÂËùʾ£º


±¦ÔËÀ³¡¤(ÖйúÇø)×îйٷ½ÍøÕ¾


ÐÐ1299 £¬ÅжÏtcp_gso_segsºÍpcountµÄ´óÓ× £¬ÈôÊÇtcp_gas_segsÓ×ÓÚpcount £¬BUG_ON¶ÏÑÔ´¥·¢µ¼ÖÂÄں˱ÀÀ£¡£


ƾ¾Ý²¹¶¡¿ÉÖª £¬skb_shift()±»tcp_skb_shift()°ü°ì £¬Ö»ÊǼÓÁËÁ½¸öÅжÏ £¬ÈçÏÂËùʾ£º

±¦ÔËÀ³¡¤(ÖйúÇø)×îйٷ½ÍøÕ¾


²¹¶¡Æ½±ðÀëÅжÏÁËskb->len+shift_len²»ÄÜ´óÓÚ65535*8×Ö½ÚºÍtcp_skb_pcount(to) + pcount²»ÄÜ´óÓÚ65535¡£µÚÒ»¸öÅжÏ £¬skb->lenÊǰµÊ¾sk_buff½á¹¹ÌåÖаµÊ¾payload³¤¶È £¬shift_len°µÊ¾Òª¹é²¢µ½skbÖеÄpayload¡£


CVE-2019-11478


¸Ã·ì϶ҲÊÇÕûÊýÒç³ö £¬ÔÚÊý¾Ý°ü³Áд«Êä¹ý³ÌÖÐ £¬½«´«Êä¶ÓÁзֶÎΪ¶à¸ö΢Ó×µÄskbs £¬ÅòÕÍskbÖÐд¶ÓÁÐÄÚ´æ²úÉúÒç³ö¡£ÔÚ´¦ÖÃSACK¿éÖÐÔ̺¬µÄskb²¢½«Æä¹é²¢ºó £¬Æ¾¾ÝGSOÅжϽøÐÐÊÇ·ñ·Ôì¬ £¬ÈôÊDZØÒª £¬Å²ÓÃtcp_fragement()º¯Êý½øÐзÔ쬡£Æ¾¾Ý²¹¶¡¿ÉÖª£º


±¦ÔËÀ³¡¤(ÖйúÇø)×îйٷ½ÍøÕ¾


²¹¶¡ÔÚtcp_fragment()º¯ÊýÖвÎÓëÁË×îÓ׿ռäÅжÏ¡£SkÊÇsock½á¹¹ÌåÀàÐÍ £¬Ã¿Ò»¸ötcpÁ´½Ó¶ÔÓ¦Ò»¸ö¡£ËùÒÔËùÓÐÒª·¢Ë͵ÄskbÊý¾Ý´óÓ×¶¼ÒªÀÛ¼Óµ½sk->sk_wmem_queuedÖÐ £¬sk->sk_wmem_queued°µÊ¾Îª¸ÃÌ×½Ó×ÖTCPд¶ÓÁлº³åÇø´óÓס£Í¨³£ÔÚʹÓÃʱ³½±ØÒªÅжϸÃÖµÊÇ·ñ¹»Óá£ÈçÏÂËùʾ£º


±¦ÔËÀ³¡¤(ÖйúÇø)×îйٷ½ÍøÕ¾


ƾ¾Ý×¢½â¿ÉÖª £¬ÅжÏ×îÐÂÁжÓskb°üËùÐèµÄ×îÓ׿Éд¿Õ¼ä¡£²¹¶¡ÖÐ £¬ÅжÏÔü×Ò·¢ËÍ»º´æÎª´óÓÚµÅ×Úµ±Ç°·¢ËͶÓÁÐÕ¼ÓÿռäµÄÒ»°ë £¬¼´»¹ÓÐ1/3ÒÔÉϵĿÕÓà¿Õ¼äʱ £¬²¢ÇÒÓ×ÓÚsk->sk_sndbuf·¢·îÉÏÏÞÄÜÁ¦¹»Õý³£·¢ËÍ £¬²»È»¾ÍÅж¨TCPд¶ÓÁÐÌ«´ó¡£


CVE-2019-11479


¸Ã·ì϶ÓÉÓÚ¹ý¶È¿÷Ëð×ÊÔ´µ¼Ö»ؾø·þÎñ¡£ÈôÊǶñÒâÊý¾Ý°ü½«MSSÑ¡ÏîÉèÖóɽÏÓ×Öµ £¬Õ⽫ÆÈʹºÍÌ¸Õ»ÆÆ·Ñ¼«¶È¸ßµÄÍøÂç»òCPU×ÊÔ´·¢ËÍÊý¾Ý°ü¿ªÏú¡£LinuxÄÚºËÖн«MSS_NOWÓ²±àÂëΪ48¡£Æ¾¾Ý²¹¶¡¿ÉÖª£º

±¦ÔËÀ³¡¤(ÖйúÇø)×îйٷ½ÍøÕ¾


½øÐÐÁËmax×î´óÖµÅжÏ £¬¶ø²»ÔÙÊǹ̶¨Ó²±àÂë¡£ÕâÀïµÄsysctl_tcp_min_snd_mss±»ÉèÖÃΪ65535 £¬ÈçÏÂËùʾ£º


±¦ÔËÀ³¡¤(ÖйúÇø)×îйٷ½ÍøÕ¾


Ô¤·ÀÁ˹¥»÷ÕßʹÓü«Ó×MSSÖµ¡£


Ó°Ïì°æ±¾¼°²¹¶¡½¨¸´


ʵʱ¸üÐÂ×îв¹¶¡»ò½ûÓÃSACKºÍ¹ýÂ˼«Ó×MSSµÄÊý¾Ý°ü¡£


CVE-2019-11477

Ó°Ïì°æ±¾£º

  • Linux 2.6.29 ~ 4.19.13£¨stable kernel releases 4.4.182,  4.9.182, 4.14.127, 4.19.52, 5.1.11Ö®±í£©

  • RHEL 8 (kernel, kernel-rt) £¬RHEL 7 (kernel, kernel-rt) £¬RHEL 6

½ûÓÃsack£º

  • sudo sysctl -w net.ipv4.tcp_sack=0

²¹¶¡£º

  • https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/davem/net.git/commit/?id=3b4929f65b0d8249f19a50245cd88ed1a2f78cff

CVE-2019-11478

Ó°Ïì°æ±¾£º

  • Linux 2.6.29 ~ 4.19.13£¨stable kernel releases 4.4.182,  4.9.182, 4.14.127, 4.19.52, 5.1.11Ö®±í£©

  • RHEL 8 (kernel, kernel-rt) £¬RHEL 7 (kernel, kernel-rt) £¬RHEL 6 £¬RHEL 5

½ûÓÃsack£º

  • sudo sysctl -w net.ipv4.tcp_sack=0

²¹¶¡£º

  • https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/davem/net.git/commit/?id=f070ef2ac66716357066b683fb0baf55f8191a2e

CVE-2019-11479

Ó°Ïì°æ±¾£º

  • Linux 2.6.29 ~ 4.19.13£¨stable kernel releases 4.4.182,  4.9.182, 4.14.127, 4.19.52, 5.1.11Ö®±í£©

  • RHEL 8 (kernel, kernel-rt) £¬RHEL 7 (kernel, kernel-rt) £¬RHEL 6 £¬RHEL 5

¹ýÂ˺ÅÁ

  • sudo iptables -A INPUT -p tcp -m tcpmss --mss 1:500 -j DROP

¹Ø¹Øtcp_mtu_probing£º

  • sysctl net.ipv4.tcp_mtu_probing

²¹¶¡£º

  • https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/davem/net.git/commit/?id=5f3e2bf008c2221478101ee72f5cb4654b9fc363

  • https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/davem/net.git/commit/?id=967c05aee439e6e5d7d805e195b3a20ef5c433d6